The Great American Parade
|
Copyright:
© 2003 Copyright Robert Burrows, All Rights Reserved Standard Copyright License
Language: English
Country: United States
|
Printed: 217 pages, 6" x 9", perfect binding, black and white interior ink Description:The concentration of American wealth in private and corporate hands today far exceeds that of the Gilded Age. Believing that such concentrations are a threat to the health of our society and that the Bush tax cuts by baldly promoting such concentrations have struck a mortal blow to democracy, a group of college students embark on a crusade to awaken America to the need to turn back those tax cuts and recall the nation to its heritage as embodied in the best of its legacies from Jefferson and Jackson, Lincoln and Teddy Roosevelt, FDR and Kennedy. This novel is the story of their crusade. [for the electronic version of this text, click on the author's name and select the electronic edition from his storefront] Keywords:Listed in: |
Stats:
Reviews:
Please log in or sign up to post a review.
Negative first: It is not the worst novel published in the English language, but as far as novels go, it's definitely not a good one. The main characters are college students but talk like old professors. The dialog is horrible and reads like the stiffest of the stiffest English you can imagine. If any college student tried to talk like that in real life, they would probably be either outcast or committed to mental health. It also doesn't seem feasible that even the most talented students would have the kind of deep insights and well thought out opinions of politics and economic policies that the author awards them. I believe that is something that even the most driven people achieve much later in life.
Positive then: the plot is interesting, albeit unrealistic, and is the only thing that kept me reading past the pages and pages of political and economical arguments that slows the story down to a crawl. It is humorous and satirical and the author can be very colorful and imaginative in his descriptions, especially of the parade itself.
But it doesn't make up for it. As a novel, it is burdened with the enormous amounts of argumentative politics which are probably the main reason for writing this book. The author's ideas (and ideals) carry some weight and are well argued and nicely researched (I assume, as there is not a single footnote or bibliography in the book), but it is unfortunate that he chose to deliver these ideas in the form of a fictional novel, which is obviously not where his talent lies. It would have been better to formulate it as an academic project, concentrating on the political message and not get bogged down with characters and dialog, which obviously got second priority in his concentration.
P.S. The Capital Times of Madison, WI made some excellent points about Weingarten's pointless bashing here.
Here's the URL of the review that caused all the fuss:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/ac2/wp-dyn?pagename=article&node=&contentId=A57528-2003Feb11¬Found=true
"Brilliant! I read your book almost at one sitting... I couldn't stop reading. Thanks for your passion and insight." - A faculty member at a Pennsylvania college
"...It is, in my professional judgment, the worst novel ever published in the English language." - Gene Weingarten, Washington Post, February 16 2003
"With skill and imagination you have left an indelible impression on the reader on a theme that is basic to the survival of democracy." - Retired Librarian of Northland College
"A truly magnificent achievement!" - Professor Adi Wimmer, American Studies Program, University of Klagenfurt (Austria)
[Click the preview to close]





