The Sourcebook is Volume 2 of a set, Volume 1 being "The Jewish Trinity: When Rabbis Believed in the Father, Son and Holy Spirit," on sale everywhere. For a free color PDF of the Sourcebook, see www.yoel.info (The free color PDF is also available from Lulu.com). To search inside this book, go to Google Print:
B&W version: http://print.google.com/print?isbn=1411601467
Color version: http://print.google.com/print?isbn=1411601475
You must be logged in to post a review.
Please log in
1
Person Reviewed This Item
By Yoel Natan
Oct 15, 2009
"Re: Unsound exegesis?" Dear Shawn McDonnell, I just happened to come across your review dated 22 Nov 2004 on 5 Dec 2004. You based your analysis just on the short preview of the B&W text. I have the entire color PDF available for download here for free: www.lulu.com/yoel The Sourcebook (vol 2) is basically the notebook from which I created The Jewish Trinity (vol 1) available for sale for as little as $12.xx (see www.yoel.info). You said that in one OT verse I interpreted the “sun” to be “Son” based on the similarities of the words. Nothing could be further from the truth. You’ll recall that a person (Satan/King of Babylon) is denoted by Venus in Isa 14:12. In other parts of Scriptures astral bodies signify persons (e.g., 2Pe 1:19; Rev 1:16; 22:16). So here in Malichi 4:2 the Sun of Righteousness denotes a person—the Son of God. Nevertheless, the doctrine of the Trinity does not stand or fall on how one translates Mal 4:2. The Hebrew grammar that you cite I... More > thoroughly debunk in Volume I, which was reviewed here on the seminary level: http://www.angelfire.com/moon/yoelnatan/bookreviews.htm So, please do take some time to review both books. Thanks! Yoel Natan< Less
