Out in Cheeseburger High life has taken a great turn when the evil serial killer has been defeated by the principal. She went out in the woods looking for his dog and heard an elderly woman crying for help and managed to save her from the murderer known as ‘The Thrower’. He kept taken his victims to a cliff to hurl them off trying to get them to land on a gargoyle statue below. After three misses he ended up being the one that landed on it. However, a new threat has come. People that the citizens aren’t fond of are dying in weird and brutal ways. First a news reporter who tries to make a man whose been competing on women’s sport look good followed by others. After the third victim the old legend the town forgot finally comes back. After one more gets killed the biggest crime gets committed. The beautiful Nurse Stephanie is kidnapped by the new killer. Now the students of Cheeseburger High band together and end the reign of terror at the monster on the book’s cover.