Things are going well in the small town of Digger's Cove. Abby Anderson is still sheriff especially since she solved the murders that happened awhile back. Her relationship with Merry Jo is going great. The only problem she has are someone has been pulling off some pranks that include apple pie and a stolen bike. Once she has that wrapped up. Abby thinks she can sit back and relax. New deputy Nikki finds a house with an open door and some blood. Abby finds the body. The question who would kill one of the nicest guys in town