Maggie Temples has lived in the small town of Brattenburg, New York, for most of her life. Working part-time at her family's bakery, Sweet Bliss, while teaching classes at the local community college. Maggie thinks life will continue in the same old, boring way, until one fateful Saturday morning, when a man from Maggie's past shows back up in Brattenburg. Luke Beckett breezes back into Maggie's life. Maggie feels the same flutter in her stomach every time she sees Luke, just like she did back in high school. She doesn't want to rush into anything with Luke, but fate seems to have a different idea for Maggie and her long-lost love. Of course, Luke comes back to Brattenburg, and Maggie, when all hell seems to break loose in the small town on the Delaware.